In response to:

What’s the best way to present work during a design critique?

The most helpful critiques I've been in start with the designer specifying what they want feedback on. If you know you don't have the visual design in a great place, but you want feedback on a specific interaction or flow, make sure you mention that. The actual fidelity of what you present depends on what you are sharing. If you want feedback on a layout or visuals, showing high fidelity mockups is helpful. If you want critique on an interaction, showing a prototype is best.

Action Items